So, I've mentioned previously about some profound thoughts of my third graders. This week we've been taking a look at the book, Hey, Little Ant by Phillip Hoose and his daughter, Hannah. This captivating picture book is written as a dialogue between a little boy and an ant. In an early illustration the youngster is poised with his sneaker hovering above a little ant with suitcases in tow. They debate about the value of the ant's life and whether or not it should be spared. Really, it's a philosophical book about the value of life if you dig deep enough.We attempted to answer the question today, "Should the ant's life be spared?" by creating a yes/no list. My students came up with 8 different rationales on both sides.
My favorites under "yes":
- Ants are a gift from Mother Nature.
- Ants help clean up our property by eating crumbs.
- Ants deserve life, liberty, and happiness, too (we studied the Declaration of Independence this year!)
- Anthills mess up our yards.
- When ants infest our houses, they bring their predators inside, too!
- Ants can spread germs and bacteria!
P.S. We finally decided that the boy should definitely not smoosh the ant.